WOYWW & Gelatoes VS Gel Sticks

Howdy folks! I have no project to share with you today. BUT, since it is What’s on Your Workdesk Wednesday here is a shot of my desk:

 

I have a lot of things started. I went to a crop Friday and scrapped 8 layouts! I might need an embellishment or two on some and I want to photograph them before I put them in my album so there they sit. I have some stamped backgrounds I have been making ready for future cards and I have my Gel Sticks AND Gelatos out. After the tutorial I did on Faber Castell Gel Sticks/Gelatos 2 weeks ago Faber Castell sent me some real Gelatos (look at me with “big girl” supplies) and I decided to try them out next to the less expensive Gel Sticks they also manufacture. They say they are formulated differently, well, they are both lovely products but YOU be the judge. Here in this video I will bust these Gelatos out of the package and try them out side by side with the Gel sticks:

Interesting…Please remember that I am not a chemist or scientist and I have no knowledge of the chemical make-up of either product (although they assure me that both the Gel Sticks and Gelatos are non-toxic) I am judging them on their feel, performance, look and working characteristics.

***Edited to add that I spoke with a lady from Faber Castell and she said that they worked with chemists to improve the gelatos (that were inspired by the kids Gel Sticks) so that they would not fade over time. Also they chose the colors in the gelato line to reflect current color trends. I will add lightfast info as it becomes available.***

Pros to the Gelatos are: More colors: 22 regular shades and 6 metallic. The 4 pack ($10) comes with a brush and clear stamp. (I have more brushes than Carter has pills so it is not a biggie for me-I’m even worse in the stamp department LOL!) I also like how they list the color name on the cap. They are sold in packs color families to coordinate with the other products in the Design Memory Craft line marketed to papercrafters to take the guesswork out of matching.

Cons to the Gelatos: Price. The 2 packs are $3.99, 4 packs (with brush and stamp)are $9.99 and the full 28 pack is $59.95

Pros to the Gel Sticks: They seem every bit as good as the Gelatos. The coverage is great, they are smooth and creamy and they blend well. You can’t beat the price at about $1 each! I bought the 12 pack of regular colors on Amazon for $11 and the 6 metallic for $7. You can get them for less if your local Joanns has them and you use a coupon too!

Cons to the Gel Sticks: Color range. There is only 18 colors and they are not labeled on the tube.

Thanks to Faber Castell for sending me the samples to review. Thanks for stopping by and til next time happy crafting!

Advertisements

31 Responses

  1. great desk photo, love the labels! how nice for you that they sent you some big girl stuff to play with! happy WOYWW!

    Like

  2. After I saw the gel stick video, I purchased from Amazon. After this video, I am not sorry. The only tricky thing with ordering from Amazon is the picture on the large package of gel sticks has a really strange picture so you are not sure what you are buying. You must read the description. Thanks for showing us both products, Lindsey.

    Like

  3. Wish I could label the stuff on my desk too! How much fun you are having with those gelatos! I don’t think they are available here! Patsy

    Like

  4. I bought the gel sticks on amazon for about 10$ and I really don’t know the difference. I had the gelatos before but really not having the color name isnt a buggy. The plastic is the color. I wonder what the difference is. Doesn’t seem like much. Thanks for sharing.

    Like

  5. Well, busy as always, love the snap of your desk.
    Krisha #30

    Like

  6. Happy speak like a pirate day and enjoy crafting
    😀
    Lisa
    #40

    Like

  7. Well, I love my Gelatos, so I didn’t watch the video, but lucky you for getting them from Farber Castell that way, that’s something I would love to have happen to me..::sigh::..anyhoo… waving hi from the hills of North Carolina 🙂

    Like

  8. Lovely busy desk there and well done on 8 layouts in a day – it would take me weeks to do those! Thanks for sharing – Sunshine Girl No. 68

    Like

  9. Lots of lovely crafty goodies on your desk Lindsay and as for Gelatos, never seen them and never tried them so thanks for the review, very useful.
    Happy WOYWW and have a creative end to the week.
    hugs {brenda} xox #98

    Like

  10. Thanks so much for the tutorial on the gel sticks and the review and comparison between the gelatos and gels. VERY interesting and something we should consider about any product I guess! I looked up on Amazon UK and was delighted to see they have the gel sticks for he equivalent of $14 but they wanted to charge $44 shipping!!!!!!!! I don’t think I shall be buying them!!!!!

    Like

  11. Thanks for this. I bought the gel sticks and haven’t tried them yet.

    Like

  12. I have been using those gelatos for a while now and really like them from Faber Castell….on my blog you can see a step by step guide when i did a layout using them to colour lace and canvas, i also like there big stamper pen….The Rubber Cafe sells them and has cheap P+P if anyone is after some
    Jackie 30
    http://scrapbangwallop.blogspot.com

    Like

  13. The desk looks great. 8LO’s? You gotta be kidding. I talk more than scrap at crops.
    Happy WOYWW!
    Tertia #47

    Like

  14. Interesting – I always like the side-by-side comparison, it’s great to help decide. and 8 layouts?? Blimey! 🙂

    Mary Anne (2)

    Like

  15. Another new item for me to try! I have never tried either product, where will I find room to put them?! Thanks for sharing!

    Like

  16. Great video Lindsay. I am sticking with Gel Sticks. I thought the gel sticks blended better too when you were painting the swatches. Seemed to have a better consistency. I love your paintbrush, lol. Count me in on the large paint brush collection. I will never be one of those artists with the four brushes, lol. I am always buying brushes.

    Like

  17. Thank you for sharing your labeled photo–awesome! And I need to come back and watch that video–I could use that tutorial on the comparison. Happy WOYWW! Sandy Leigh #36

    Like

  18. Thanks for the review!
    I have been thinking of investing in some gelatos.
    I have a friend who does beautiful work with them! 🙂
    Mary Jo #115

    Like

  19. Wow super organised on your desk, I’d never heard of gelatos before.
    Happy WOYWW
    Cath

    Like

  20. Thank you for doing this demo I have the gelatos and have had them for ages but your demo has enlightened me.

    Eliza #45

    Like

  21. You’ve certainly got a well-organized desk and it looks like everything has its place.
    Can’t say I’ve ever seen or heard of Gelatoes but have found your video very interesting. Just goes to show that buying ‘the best’ isn’t necessarily the best in the long run but how generous of Faber Castell to offer you the samples to try out.

    Happy Crafting!
    Sue @ #118
    x

    Like

  22. Thanks for the snapshot of your desk, ooooo Gelatos they look fab. Happy WOYWW Gillian #87

    Like

  23. so i am really bummed out… i saw the weekly webisode on Paperwishes (love) and i got suckered into buying the Gelatos…had i known that they had a “kids” version (with better colors and more metalics) i would have jumped on it! oh well… i am gonna buy some of the “gel sitcks” on Amazon so i can get the different colors. i cannot believe how crafty you are.. sparkly eyeshadow for some added bling and a clothes pin with “funny foam and a rubber band” as a blending tool.. how cool is that! Wish i had your mad Macguiver skills!

    Like

  24. Thanks for the reviews – I’ve never tried either of these products – they look interesting.
    Bernice #3

    Like

  25. Good review, Lindsay–I have the Gelatos, and REALLY like them, but have never tried the other brand.

    Like

  26. 8 scrapbook pages to embellish?! Can’t wait to see the finished articles.

    Like

  27. That’s cool you get to sample those and with all of us desk hopping we get an idea if we’d like to purchase them!Tamika#137

    Like

  28. Thanks Lindsay…I too bought the gel sticks after your great demo…I previously had some gelatos and really can’t tell the difference either!
    Paper Hugs,
    Jan

    Like

  29. awesome comparison. I have two questions… Gelatos and gels seem to me along the line of pastels. So my concern is do they “dry” and if they do is the color permanent or can it “rub off” on something like a page protector or opposite album page if I used it in my scrapbook for color wash or stenciling. The second is its archival quality… will it eventually “bleed” into other parts of my page?? Thanks!!

    Like

    • I have not noticed any bleeding of color or any color shift on either the gel sticks or gelatos. The companies says the gelatoes are lightfast and acid free but they did not say that the gel sticks weren’t. I typically blend them out a bit so I don’t leave big streaks of color that would rub on a page protector but using them to ink edges and add color and blend it out there has been no transferrence of gelato to my page protector and I know other scrapbookers who use them a lot.

      Like

  30. Just watched a live streamed video of some Faber Castel people and they asked about the differences. All they said was the gelatos had been “improved” from the gel sticks. I am personally enjoying the gel sticks!

    Like

Tell me what YOU think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: